Sunday, October 1, 2017

Doctor Blake Mysteries: “Mortal Coil” (December Media, Australian Broadcasting Corporation, ITV, 2014)

by Mark Gabrish Conlan • Copyright © 2017 by Mark Gabrish Conlan • All rights reserved

About the only thing I got to watch on TV last night — Lifetime was doing an interminable documentary mini-series on the murder of Laci Peterson by her estranged husband Scott (and the ominous decision to charge him with two murders because Laci was pregnant when she was killed — as an ardent pro-choicer I have a problem with anything that hints that a fetus is a separate being that has an actionable right to “life”) — was a Doctor Blake Mysteries series episode called “Mortal Coil.” It begins at a funeral during which the pallbearers are having unexpected trouble with the sheer weight of the coffin — and when they drop it on its way to the grave they find out why: it contains two dead bodies, the one they were supposed to be burying and that of Sid Bartel (Bruce Gleeson), an old handyman in the village of Ballarat, Australia where The Doctor Blake Mysteries are set (Doctor Lucien Blake himself, played by Craig McLachlan, being a young man who grew up in Ballarat, went off to serve as a military medic in World War II, then elected to return and resettle in Ballarat in the late 1950’s). Of course this raises the obvious mystery-type questions: how did Sid’s body get into that coffin, how did Sid die and, most important, was it foul play and therefore something the police should work on finding out and prosecuting? Later the police and Doctor Blake encounter another double-occupied coffin in which the unauthorized occupant turns out to be Martin Callow (Andrew S. Gilbert), owner of the mortuary from which the bodies were supposed to be buried. Doctor Blake, despite the opposition of the local police (who at one point tell him to wait in the police station while they check out the latest lead he’s given them — which, of course, he doesn’t), stakes out the funeral home and finds Martin’s widow Lydia (Esther Stephens) has been having an affair with the mortuary’s delivery driver, which of course leads Blake to suspect that she and the driver conspired to knock off her husband so they could be together. 

But Dr. Blake finally pins the murders on Harold Morris (Dennis Coard), a nasty guy we’ve hated from the moment he was introduced and started bullying everyone, who along with his two sons were once enforcers for an Australian labor union whose job it was to beat up and intimidate scabs. Morris threatens Dr. Blake himself but Blake gets the gun away from him, and just when (in the best-written scene of Stuart Page’s script) Morris has taunted Blake with the idea that Blake doesn’t have the nerve to shoot him, especially since as a doctor he’s pledged to save lives instead of taking them, Blake shoots him — not in the chest but in the knee to incapacitate him so he can be arrested and held in the local hospital by the police. The police finally get the evidence they need to convict Morris when his son Steven (Dan Hamill) turns state’s evidence and confesses his own role in the crimes — the other son having disappeared earlier and possibly, Page’s script hints, himself having been “offed” by his father when he wanted to turn them all in. The motive for the killings, as nearly as I could figure it out, was that Martin Callow had been involved in Australia’s labor wars on the management side and that Harold Morris had a vendetta against him and was determined to kill him — and that poor Sid Bartel, a handyman who still transported himself in a horse-drawn vehicle (itself inspiring some murderous rage among local drivers who found his 2-mile-an-hour cart blocking the way of their cars on the road), was just in the wrong place at the wrong time: he witnessed Harold shooting Martin and therefore Harold shot him too. I have no idea if the history of organized labor in Australia was anywhere nearly as violent as this episode makes it sounds, and despite my opposition to terrorism in the service of any cause I still have a rather clammy feeling about a story in which union activists are the villains, but this was a quite good Doctor Blake episode in a show I’ve come to like for its understated British-style approach to murder (the only on-screen scenes of violence we see are Dr. Blake’s incapacitation of the villain and a few flashbacks representing Blake’s speculations on how the murders might have occurred) and the cleverness of the writing, even though in a few episodes (though not this one) the cleverness has got a bit too clever for its own good.